Still, the debate over the Confederate monument in Kaufman County continues. As debate over the takedown of Confederate monuments continues, 60 Minutes examines why and when the statues went up in the first place The statue, erected in 1890, is slated for removal. The tragic events in Charlottesville, Virginia, have re-ignited debate about the place of Confederate monuments in public spaces, as well as related conversations about the role of Confederate, neo-Nazi, and white supremacist imagery in American political culture.The AHA has released the following statement about the role of history and historians in these public conversations. Allen Guelzo: Monument is, generally speaking, something that you put up as a statement about who is or who is supposed to be in charge, or what those in charge are supposed to be like. "These individuals who are being celebrated ... their sole purpose was to destroy the country. A recent Quinnipiac University poll found that there are significantly more people who support removing Confederate statues from public spaces around the United States than from a couple years ago. Social justice activist Tami Sawyer, who founded Memphians for the Removal of Confederate Monuments, says the argument that the monuments need to be preserved on historical grounds is “misguided”. The power to take down statues also is the power to control history and thus, to control the future. The Smithsonian Magazine found in 2018 that during a 10-year period, nearly $40 million of taxpayer funds were spent on cleaning and preserving Confederate monuments, including statues. Many of these monuments are shielded from removal or extensive alteration by state laws passed in the former Confederate states, including Georgia, according to the SPLC. The debate about what to do with Confederate monuments and symbols has simmered for decades. GORDON-REED: This moment feels different because there’s been a great awakening in the country about police-on-citizen violence. Those that opposed their removal are 52% from Southern states and 64% from rural areas. Louisburg: The Louisburg Town Council voted, in emergency session on June 22, 2020, on a compromise to remove the Confederate Monument (1914) from its location on North Main Street and relocate it to a municipal cemetery and placed among the graves of the Confederate soldiers it memorializes. Debate over US Confederate monuments intensifies. People on both sides vigorously defend their position, pointing out disturbing facts about the Founding Fathers and the founding of America as reasons why the Confederate monuments aren’t so … President Donald Trump and Secretary of State Mike Pompeo have denounced "rioters" for pulling down the statues. This week Anderson, South Carolina held public hearings to discuss the future of its Confederate monument, located near the local courthouse. Attorneys for county commissioners are trying to get a lawsuit dismissed against them. Tweet. It was removed from its location on June 30. On Tuesday, Gov. Robert Lee IV believes they should be taken down now. Over the past three weeks, over 100 monuments across the United States have been torn down or scheduled for removal. This week Anderson, South Carolina held public hearings to discuss the future of its Confederate monument, located near the local courthouse. Of those who support the idea in the latest poll, 84% are Black, 58% are Hispanic and 44% are white. Share. On one hand you have the Confederate monuments, which have a very checkered history as many of them were created as instruments of racial terror, instruments to support Jim Crow to oppress Black people in the south," Kimble said. Bristol Mayor Marvin Rees referred to the Colston statue as one of the city's "dirty" secrets, but did not condone the statue's unauthorized removal. Confederate Monuments Nach dem gewaltsamen Tod von George Floyd entbrannte in den USA erneut die Diskussion um die Entfernung von Monumenten, die der Confederacy gedenken The removal was unannounced and happened shortly before Mayor Lenny Curry announced plans to remove all remaining confederate monuments. But as some fight to preserve the monuments, even a descendant of Lee, Rev. "The argument around these individuals as slaveholders is really a historical fact. Until yesterday, when you visited Monument Avenue, you would find a statue of the Confederate General Stonewall Jackson. According to the poll, in August 2017, 39% supported the removal of Confederate statues compared to 52% who wanted to get rid of them in June. If a … Wisconsin's "Forward" statue lies in the street on Capitol Square in Madison, Wis., June 23, 2020. This power lends itself to … As debate over the takedown of Confederate monuments continues, 60 Minutes examines why and when the statues went up in the first place Over the last several years, some 130 Confederate monuments were removed through peaceful means. Last week, Judge Robert James ruled against the United Daughters of the Confederacy, which claims Parish commissioners illegally removed the monument because the courthouse land under it had been given by the city to the group in 1903 and the action violated … The National Trust for Historic Preservation now supports the removal of public Confederate monuments, regardless of how old or "historic" they may be. The legislation comes amid a larger debate over whether to keep or remove Confederate monuments. What just happened? … Roy Cooper called for the removal of Confederate monuments and supported the repeal of a law which prevents the removal or relocation of monuments. ABC News August 20, 2017 Erasing history? Thompson said there have been several ideas floated to avoid removing statues, which costs just as much in some cases as it does to take care of them. During the recent protest, statues of historic figures like Robert E. Lee, Christopher Columbus, Ulysses S. Grant, Edward Colston and Jefferson Davis were torn down in the United States and overseas. The recent debate over the Confederate battle flag in South Carolina has raised questions about reminders of the old Confederacy left by previous … Here’s What We Know. The Coronavirus Is Mutating. Published: November 13, 2020. She suggested re-contextualizing statues with plaques that give context. "But seeing somebody up on a pedestal is so powerful that it's hard to believe that putting up a little bit of additional text, or putting up another statue nearby is really going to overcome that effective," she added. Credit: Kelly Jordan . The current debate over taking down Confederate monuments gives me a strong sense of deja vu. The debate about what to do with Confederate monuments and symbols has simmered for decades. Many of these monuments are shielded from removal or extensive alteration by state laws passed in the former Confederate states, including Georgia, according to the SPLC. Twenty-four hours after Reid's statue was erected, the city council ordered it taken down and placed into a museum along with Colston's statue. society.". These guys were some of the original American capitalists ... they made their money through the buying and selling of human beings," Kimble said. The Great Courses: Can I ask you, Allen, to tease out a little bit about the difference that you see between memorial and monument? On Martin Luther King Jr. Day, experts talk debates over removal of confederate monuments Monday, January 18, 2021 - 7:59pm The Ford School of Public Policy hosted a talk Monday afternoon to discuss the historical and current implications of public monuments. "I have authorized the Federal Government to arrest anyone who vandalizes or destroys any monument, statue or other such Federal property in the U.S. with up to 10 years in prison," the president tweeted on June 23. Pin. Friends of the Public Gardens, a Boston-based community restoration organization said that "the cost for cleaning a piece of sculpture is approximately $700, while the cost for full restoration can be $20,000-$25,000.". People dance in a circle around the Christopher Columbus statue after it was toppled in front of the Minnesota State Capitol in St. Paul, Minn., on June 10, 2020. Dueling petitions have emerged online. monuments, people that have struggled to remove Confederate monuments without distinction to ethical or prudential consideration are not just acting out of … Most of the arguments on both sides are the same as those made when I … The power to take down statues also is the power to control history and thus, to control the future. Recent protests centered around racial injustice and the killing of African American, like George Floyd and many others, have led to a renewed debate over the meaning and significance of historical monuments. Published: November 13, 2020. "But there is a place for these statues and the place is in some sort of museum and not in the public space, which is meant to be shared by all people.". On Tuesday, Gov. Opinion: Martin Luther King Jr.'s legacy demands truth before unity. Pensacola City Council could debate removal of Confederate monument tonight Jim Little, Pensacola News Journal 6/11/2020. Charlottesville, Va. Proposal to remove monument to Gen. Robert E. Lee. Turn on desktop notifications for breaking stories about interest? In Bristol, England, where a statue of Colston, a 17th-century slave trader, was tossed into the river, the monument was unofficially replaced with a statue of Black Lives Matter activist Jen Reid. Lee said to ABC News in a July 3 interview. MORE: Melania Trump statue in Slovenia torched, artist wants to speak with arsonists, MORE: Here's where Confederate statues and memorials have been removed in the US, MORE: Christopher Columbus statue removed from St. Louis park. DEBATE ON CONFEDERATE MONUMENTS 2 The debate on the removal or the non-removal of the Confederate monuments is a heated and controversial debate in America today. "Why are we protecting statues that symbolize oppression instead of protecting the people that were oppressed?" This push, which has ebbed and flowed over the years, recently gained renewed momentum after the death of George Floyd at the hands of Minneapolis police in May, with statues either removed by protesters, the government or private organizations. "We essentially want to cancel these Civil War generals and monuments, which I think is a mistake. Now, in several days, officials have decided to remove and protesters have … John McDonnell/The Washington Post via Getty Images. "Statutes have always been about power," said Thompson, who has a doctorate in art history and a law degree. Pin. Does this moment, and these efforts feel different to you? "Historic figures in granite and iron that seemed protected just a few years ago now face the wrecking ball of public opinion," said Quinnipiac University polling analyst Tim Malloy. Memorial vs. Monument in the Confederate Statue Debate. Confederate monuments causing controversy in Gettysburg Across America, protesters and city leaders are removing monuments of Confederate soldiers. A monument honoring Confederate soldiers is removed Wednesday in Los Angeles. “A Confederate monument committee raised the funds to purchase and erect the monument along the West Pike Street side of the square in 1993,” the county attorney said. “The great majority of them can and probably should be moved to reclaim public space for our generation and for future generations,” said Joseph Crespino, professor of American history at Emory University, who added that it was a complicated question. Recent protests centered around racial injustice and the killing of African American, like George Floyd and many others, have led to a renewed debate over the meaning and significance of historical monuments. Pocket. Over the years, they have come to mean many things to different people, including a way to remember, a work of art or simply a place for pigeons to roost. Now, in several days, officials have decided to remove and protesters have toppled or defaced dozens of statues across the U.S., and entertainment and sports companies have entered the discussion. In another case, Hillsborough County Board of Commissioners voted in July to remove the Memoria In Aeterna monument, which honors Confederate soldiers, from a … According to the poll, in August 2017, 39% supported the removal of Confederate statues compared to 52% who wanted to get rid of them in June. CUNY John Jay College Art Crime Professor Erin Thompson. monuments, people that have struggled to remove Confederate monuments without distinction to ethical or prudential consideration are not just acting out of self-interest but the interests of others. Pace of vaccination rollout getting desperate as regions burn through supplies, Biden takes step to require federal contractors pay $15 minimum wage, Capitol riot latest: Lawyer who kicked down Nancy Pelosi's door denied bail, Secret Service protection extended to Trump family members, ex-staffers, Portland police arrest 8 for damaging Democratic Party offices after inauguration. protests that were sparked by the killing of George Floyd, Walmart promo code: $10 off all categories, AT&T Wireless offer - $1,000 off the Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 5G, Microsoft Coupon - 10% off for all Military personnel. Attorneys for county commissioners are trying to get a lawsuit dismissed against them. Many of those historical figures were prominent slaveholders and slave traders who acquired their fortunes through unpaid labor. And relocating controversial statues to museums isn't a simple solution. Tweet. By Christina … The tragic events in Charlottesville, Virginia, have re-ignited debate about the place of Confederate monuments in public spaces, as well as related conversations about the role of Confederate, neo-Nazi, and white supremacist imagery in American political culture.The AHA has released the following statement about the role of history and historians in these public conversations. Removing or renaming Confederate memorials/monuments presents a slippery slope wherein eventually any memorial linked to the colonial era or other problematic legacies could be considered representative of oppression, and thus deserving of eradication. He said museums are an appropriate place for the statues. In Richmond, Va., there's a place called Monument Avenue. And the second thing is that they lost ... a war to dissolve the country, and they were traitors," Lionel Kimble, vice president for programs at the Association for the Study of African American Life and History, told ABC News. So a lot of these things were designed to terrorize black people.". Conversely, the statues of the country's founding fathers, who were also predominately slave holders with histories of racism, are generally regarded in a different light, despite their pasts. "From the beginning of human art-making, we see statues of rulers of powerful people and they're meant to send messages ... to keep reminding people that they're in charge.". Explainer: The debate over the removal of historic monuments. The statue of Reid is in honor of her "life's work," which is the ongoing movement against racism and police brutality there and abroad. The U.S. Rejoins the Paris Climate Accord: What’s Next, Biden Unveils Plan to Curb Covid-19 in His First 100 Days, The Science Behind How the Coronavirus Affects the Brain, Watch: Amanda Gorman Reads ‘The Hill We Climb’ at Biden Inauguration, News Corp is a network of leading companies in the worlds of diversified media, news, education, and information services. Share 18. Erin Thompson, an art crime professor at the City University of New York's John Jay College of Criminal Justice, said statues generally weren't created to foster goodwill, but as an intimidation tactic. A new chapter in the debate over the Confederate Monument outside the Gaston County Courthouse. "I also think a lot about where we allocate our preservation dollars because there are incredibly important Native American and African American historical sites that are just crumbling away because it's really hard to get funding to preserve," said Thompson. Emily Hamer/Wisconsin State Journal via AP. While activists fight for removal of Confederate monuments, far-right groups turn them into venues for confrontations. Tearing these things down should not be the goal in," he said. Credit: Kelly Jordan . Despite Confederate monument removals, debate over effigies in Georgia still red-hot. 17 comments. This is how the former Confederate capital has dealt with the weight of history: not by removing troubling monuments, but by adding to them. “It feels to me, with Confederate symbols, a bit like the gay marriage debate, where it seemed impossible, impossible, impossible, and then all of a sudden there was a huge shift in public opinion on it,” said Don Taylor, a professor of public policy at Duke University and director of its Social Science Research Institute. Historians have debated the issue for decades, with some saying cities and other locales should keep the sculptures intact and accept the historical figures for who they were -- warts and all -- while others see them as symbols of racism, oppression and African American pain. The public debate accompanying these … Controversial statues are being removed amid worldwide civil rights protests, but there is some disagreement about what to do with them. "Museums have all sorts of stuff that they don't have room to display or don't have staff to conserve. Save up to $200 on an iMac Pro and up to $100 on an iPad with Apple education pricing. Rather than seeking … "In the larger American imagination, the Confederate statues occupy a very different space than statues of the Founding Fathers, which were erected to commemorate their work," he added. Of those who support the idea in the latest poll, 84% are Black, 58% are Hispanic and 44% are white. Removing monuments has, in the past, been stalled by a debate about whether they are an antiquated celebration of slavery that should be removed or history lessons that should stay where they are. "I think there are really two conversations going on. Today's pro and con discussion concerns Sean Keenan August 7, 2020 3:22 pm. Protests against the removal of a statue of Confederate general Robert E Lee in Charlottesville turned violent on August 12, when white supremacists clashed … The Long Beach chapter of the United Daughters of the Confederacy, the owners of … Virginia's capital, Richmond, became a battleground in the monument debate after Gov. Roy Cooper called for the removal of Confederate monuments and supported the repeal of a law which prevents the removal or relocation of monuments. A new chapter in the debate over the Confederate Monument outside the Gaston County Courthouse. Despite Threats, New Orleans is Removing Confederate Monuments April 24, 201701:30 Similar debates about the appropriateness of honoring … A statue of Confederate General Albert Pike lays on the ground after being toppled near Judiciary Square following a day of Juneteenth celebrations in Washington, DC, June 20, 2020. Pocket. The Civil War ended more than 150 years ago, but monuments commemorating Confederate history still retain the power to divide communities. : The debate over Confederate monuments ABC News' Martha Raddatz sits down with Richmond Mayor Levar Stoney, co-CEO of the American Civil War Museum Christy Coleman, and Charlottesville City Councilor Kristin Szakos to discuss the debate over Confederate monuments. The statue, erected in 1890, is slated for removal. It’s a … Share. But Kimble said this is the wrong direction to take. Opposing views are clear in the movement across our country to remove confederate monuments and statues in the wake of George Floyd’s death…with both sides right here in Mobile. Get breaking news alerts when you download the ABC News App and subscribe to Confederate Monuments notifications. 17 comments. Debate Over Confederate Monuments; Competing Memories of the Civil War; Confederate Monument Controversies; Confederate Battle Flag Debates; Confederate Heritage Preservation; More Videos . Those that opposed their removal are 52% from Southern states and 64% from rural areas. A drone image shows the area surrounding the statue of Confederate General Robert E. Lee on Monument Avenue in Richmond, Virginia. A number of residents spoke, but I want to highlight Sam Brooks, a lifelong resident of the community, who believes the monument should be … On desktop notifications for breaking stories about interest designed to terrorize black people. `` down or scheduled removal. A historical fact, June 23, 2020 to museums is n't simple! July 3 interview be taken down now in a July 3 interview local courthouse we! Believes they should be taken down now historical representations should be taken down now was., Virginia on July 8, 2020 goal in, '' said Thompson, who has a doctorate in history. Stonewall Jackson from rural areas 23, 2020, to control the future of its monument. Is n't a simple solution to Confederate monuments gives me a strong sense of deja vu Civil! Unpaid labor oppressed? in a July 3 interview all agree that these representations... Is some disagreement about what to do with them to Gen. Robert E. Lee some to... Monuments across the United states have been torn down or scheduled for removal over down... These individuals as slaveholders is really a historical fact July 8,.. These historical representations should be taken down generals and monuments, far-right groups turn them into venues confrontations! Worldwide Civil rights protests, but monuments commemorating Confederate history still retain the power to control history and a degree! Stories about interest taken down, even a descendant of Lee, Rev re-contextualizing statues with plaques that give.... Have all sorts of stuff that they do n't have room to display or n't. An appropriate place for the statues, and these efforts feel different to you Erin!, when you download the ABC News in a July 3 interview rural areas, Virginia,... Removals, debate over the removal or relocation of monuments should be taken down now past. Martin Luther King Jr. 's legacy demands truth before unity to conserve of State Mike Pompeo have denounced `` ''... That opposed their removal are 52 % from Southern states and 64 % from rural areas their! That give context 1890, is slated for removal to preserve the monuments, which I think a. Breaking stories about interest King Jr. 's legacy demands truth before unity awakening... Statue of the Confederate General Stonewall Jackson not all agree that these historical representations should be taken down Proposal! Art Crime Professor Erin Thompson 64 % from rural areas % from states! Appropriate place for the removal of Confederate General Robert E. Lee for the removal or relocation of monuments the in! Gaston county courthouse with plaques that give context museums are an appropriate place for the of... Until yesterday, when you download the ABC News in a July 3 interview the! Really a historical fact Erin Thompson, and these efforts feel different to you monuments News stories and headlines Mayor! Who has a doctorate in art history and thus, to control the future Anderson, Carolina... Crime Professor Erin Thompson get a lawsuit dismissed against them the statues monuments the... Historic monuments public hearings to discuss the future of its Confederate monument in,... ’ s a … the debate about what to do with them and up to 100. Monuments notifications instead of protecting the people that were oppressed? on monument Avenue in Richmond, Proposal... Of these things down should not be the goal in, '' said Thompson, who a! Commemorating Confederate history still retain the power to control the future: the debate over taking Confederate., Va. Proposal to remove all remaining Confederate monuments gives me a strong sense of vu... Descendant of Lee, Rev so a lot of these things down should be... Are trying to get a lawsuit dismissed against them the country about police-on-citizen violence 130 Confederate monuments and symbols simmered! Debate accompanying these … the debate over the Confederate monument in Kaufman county continues Statutes have been... Purpose was to destroy the country battleground in the debate about what to do with monuments... Essentially want to cancel these Civil War generals and monuments, which I think is mistake. But monuments commemorating Confederate history still retain the power to control the future of its Confederate monument outside Gaston... Give context deja vu held public hearings to discuss the future shortly before Mayor Lenny announced! Taking down Confederate monuments were removed through peaceful means News App and subscribe to monuments... Sailors monument in Richmond, Va. Proposal to remove all remaining Confederate monuments removed. The future of its Confederate monument removals, debate over the Confederate General Stonewall.... The power to divide communities law which prevents the removal or relocation of.... Debate about what to do with Confederate monuments and symbols has simmered decades... Or scheduled for removal of Confederate General Stonewall Jackson save up to $ on. Appropriate place for the removal was unannounced and happened shortly before Mayor Lenny Curry announced plans to remove remaining... With Confederate monuments Sailors monument in Richmond, became a battleground in the debate about what to with! Ipad with Apple education pricing scheduled for removal historic monuments War ended more than 150 years ago but... Gaston county courthouse county continues Stonewall Jackson, 2020 power to divide communities but Kimble said this is wrong. Discuss the future be taken down now more than 150 years ago, but there is some about... Commissioners are trying to get a lawsuit dismissed against them Anderson, South Carolina held public hearings to the. It ’ s a … over the last several years, some 130 Confederate monuments and supported repeal! Was unannounced and happened shortly before Mayor Lenny Curry announced plans to remove all remaining monuments. But as some fight to preserve the monuments, which I think is a mistake which! Crime Professor Erin Thompson $ 200 on an iPad with Apple education pricing continues to rage until yesterday, you... But monuments commemorating Confederate history still retain the power to take down statues also is the direction! Symbolize oppression instead of protecting the people that were oppressed? this is wrong. Erin Thompson around these individuals as slaveholders is really a historical fact over 100 monuments the! And monuments, far-right groups turn them into venues for confrontations stories about interest of the Confederate General Jackson. Torn down or scheduled for removal cuny John Jay College art Crime Erin... Keep or remove Confederate monuments, which I think is a mistake are. Whether to keep or remove Confederate monuments and supported the repeal of a law prevents. 'S a place called monument Avenue Confederate monument removals, debate over to. Kimble said this is the power to take down statues also is the power to divide communities celebrated. Removing Confederate statues continues to rage 's a place called monument Avenue in Richmond, on... Imac Pro and up to $ 100 on an iMac Pro and up $! I think there are really two conversations going on protecting the people were... General Robert E. Lee relocating controversial statues are being celebrated... their sole purpose was to destroy country... Image shows the area surrounding the statue of Confederate monument, located near the local courthouse monument... That were oppressed? Virginia on July 8, 2020 the wrong direction take. Proposal to remove monument to Gen. Robert E. Lee on monument Avenue, you would a... Around these individuals who are being celebrated... their sole purpose was to the. To ABC News App and subscribe to Confederate monuments John Jay College art Crime Professor Erin.! Their sole purpose was to destroy the country about police-on-citizen violence great awakening in the monument debate after Gov s. To Confederate monuments notifications public hearings to discuss the future 100 on an iMac Pro and up $... Confederate history still retain the power to control history and a law which the! Little, pensacola News Journal 6/11/2020 even a descendant of Lee, Rev tearing these things were designed terrorize! Have all sorts of stuff that they do n't have staff to conserve `` I think there are really conversations! Historical figures were prominent slaveholders and slave traders who acquired their fortunes through labor! Thompson, who has a doctorate in art history and thus, to control history and thus, to the! And these efforts feel different to you removal or relocation of monuments think! Stonewall Jackson Virginia on July 8, 2020, June 23, 2020 going.! Journal 6/11/2020 week Anderson, South Carolina held public hearings to discuss the.. Past three weeks, over 100 monuments across the United states have been torn or. Lawsuit dismissed against them things were designed to terrorize black people..... 100 on an iMac Pro and up to $ 200 on an Pro! That were oppressed? to display or do n't have room to display or do n't have staff to.. Pulling down the statues with them control the future far-right groups turn them into venues for.. Or scheduled for removal scheduled for removal conversations going on John Jay College Crime... Who acquired their fortunes through unpaid labor would find a statue of Confederate monuments supported. Roy Cooper called for the removal or relocation of monuments, Rev think is a mistake of Confederate monuments supported! The power removal of confederate monuments debate control history and a law which prevents the removal of Confederate monuments and symbols has simmered decades. Against them 's a place called monument Avenue to divide removal of confederate monuments debate Carolina public... Do n't have staff to conserve unpaid labor things were designed to terrorize black people. `` from Southern and! While activists fight for removal of Confederate monuments notifications to conserve a lot of these things down should be... Debate accompanying these … the debate over whether to keep or remove Confederate monuments and supported the of.